5spd vs auto

[mag]

How does the 5spd's tranny's hold up? I prefer a 5sdp over an auto, but am curious as to how it lasts. Also, how weak does the 5spd get if you go to 31" tires? Is it livable? I drive 55 + miles a day, and the 5spd would help a little in millage? Any input would be helpful. Thanks

[Warlock]

I don't know about the 5 speeds in the cherokees but using a 5-speed will help some on gas mileage if you can keep your foot out of it (too much)

[lonegpr]

The five speed is tough enough to take that type of driving. I've got a 5-speed in my TJ, but the '96 XJ that my wife and I had was a 4-speed auto. I think the auto is a better tranny for this type of vehicle.

[Jason, aka: Jeepin.com]

The XJ's 5-sp will hold up to 31's with no problem, heck, it'll hold up to 33's no problem. I personally prefer the auto though, the mileage difference is pretty small I think, maybe 1-2mpg at the most, and there are mods you can do to get a little extra mpg out of the engine. Personally, I wouldn't let the mileage determine the tranny you get, get the one you'd rather use. Sticks are a ***** in stop and go traffic, and IMHO the only advantage a stick has offroad is the lower 1st gear. ;)

[ROKSURF]

I have grown up utilizing manual trannies. I happen to like them by being able to utilize the engine's power band more effectively. Traffic driving- it sucks! Climbing hills or starting off on a hill can be tricky, but anything can be over rated. Autos are fine, I think the major thing is personal preference.